An illustrated guide to what’s wrong with MMP

An illustrated guide to what’s wrong with MMP

In order to make a couple of points about MMP, I first have to take us on a bit of a dumpster dive. Please stand clear of the monkey.

Firstly, here is something I’ve been hearing a bit:

The thing you have to bear in mind is a lot of these electorates vote for the local candidate they really like and it has nothing to do with the party vote.

I beg to differ.

Going into this 2026 election National held 44 electorates. Almost half were held by someone who had won the seat only once. That’s not really what you’d describe as the local MP everyone votes for because they like them so much.

National has had 131 electorate MPs since 1996. The typical one won the seat just twice. There are a few names like Judith Collins and Louise Upston and Todd McClay and Nick Smith who got returned election after election, but that’s not how it typically goes. 

Only 20 of the 89 who have now left politics won five times or more. Again not really what you’d describe as: This National party MP is just so special to us we’ll keep on electing them no matter what.

Secondly, it’s worth bearing in mind that each electorate vote is still decided by ye olde First Past the Post vote.

That is to say: in your electorate vote you can still get to feel like your vote counted for nothing.

12 of my 18 elections, I have cast my vote in the North Shore electorate and never has it been for the successful candidate. You could put a monkey in a blue rosette and come election night that monkey would surely have a majority north of 15,000.

But are they good local MPs? Well, George Gair was. But generally what our duly elected local MP does is limited to wringing their hands about the traffic on Lake Road and then making themselves scarce.

This election we had a lot of people here in the seaside village steaming about a development that in fact I don’t reject out of hand because I hold fond hopes for a future Devonport that’s quite ambitious and quite removed from the present arrangement. But that’s not the issue I want to explore here today.

My present point is that people have been steaming about the development going into the woeful and wrong Fast Track system and demanding of our MP Simon Watts: WTF Simon? and getting only crickets. But come election night, he got the usual stonking majority.

Maggie Barry was much the dismal same. You come to expect it.

The thing you have to bear in mind is a lot of these electorates vote for the local candidate they really like, they say. I have my doubts.

Thirdly,

Here is what people who are rich like about First Past the Post: it gets them the result they want.

Rich bastards don’t like sharing power. Rich bastards think their richness bestows upon them superior power and wisdom. Rich bastards think they know best.

NOT ALL RICH BASTARDS, granted.  But plenty of the really obnoxious ones want to call the shots and if some hobbling of democracy would aid that cause, then they are fucking into it.

Fourth: a question I hear Hooton has been asking audiences: Who here voted for MMP? Did anyone? Meaning: let’s pretend it was never the right thing to do and no-one here was foolish enough to support it.

Well fuck that noise, let’s recall how MMP got passed: with a thumping majority.

Let’s also recall the reason MMP ever got passed: deepest frustration with both major parties. Absent that outrage, it is really really hard to get people interested in a topic like this.

Fortunately the stars aligned and we made the change and it became possible for many more of us to cast a vote that counted.

So, to recap:

An electorate vote may not be quite so much the precious thing people assert it to be.

Rich bastards and their mates don’t like MMP because it makes it harder to call the shots.

Now let’s apply this to the question at hand: What do we say to people with their knives out for MMP?

First we say this: The bloody thing’s got out of whack.

Here’s what we had in 1996:

  • 120 seats in total
  • 60 general electorates
  • 5 Māori electorates
  • 55 list seats

Here’s what we have in 2026 (before overhang):

  • Still 120 seats in total
  • 16 general electorates on the South Island, 48 general electorates on the North Island, and 7 Māori electorates. That comes to 71.
  • 49 list seats

Why? The total stays at 120 and the South Island always gets 16 general seats. The North Island’s number of seats is set by its population relative to the South Island, so as the North grows it gains electorates.

It’s a bit like that thing where each time you tell a lie, god kills a puppy, only here what’s happened is that each time we make another electorate, we lose another list seat.

And so now, because every electorate seat is sacred, the parliament gets made bigger if the party vote fails to match the electorate vote. And this has just happened because National put up an absolute dud root of a PM and rich bastards egged on everyone who aspires to be a rich bastard to party vote ACT.

(Yes, it’s true to say hey wait on, the result more or less matched what the polls were saying anyway. However what that misses is that the polls correctly measured a party vote that had already been rearranged inside the right bloc. What it didn’t measure didn’t measure was the electorate vote that turned that rearrangement into 11 extra seats.)

Or to refrain the short version of that: The bloody thing’s got out of whack, and the essential point is  we need to get back to either 60/60 or so (plus Māori seats) or whatever larger equal number we desire of list versus electorate. Fix that first, and then debate whatever else you like, if you think you can get people interested. 

But good luck with that.

We changed to MMP because people were so frustrated they were not being heard.

We changed to MMP because people felt their vote was not counting for anything.

The dumbest thing we could do now is roll over and give some rich monkeys what they want.

More Issues

Become a full member